US Senators Challenge CFTC Order on Prediction Markets Over State Court Rulings

Several Democratic members of the U.S. Senate have called on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to reverse its recent directive requiring prediction market platforms to stop blocking users in certain states.

In a letter sent to the regulator on Monday, the lawmakers argued that the order conflicts with active court rulings that have required platforms to restrict access to certain event contracts. They warned that the CFTC's position could encourage companies to violate existing judicial orders while legal disputes remain unresolved.

The CFTC recently informed regulated prediction market exchanges, including Kalshi and Polymarket, that state-by-state restrictions, commonly known as geofencing, may violate federal derivatives laws. The agency gave platforms 30 days to remove these restrictions or provide an explanation for why they could not comply.

CFTC Chairman Mike Selig maintains that exchanges registered as designated contract markets (DCMs) fall under federal oversight, limiting the authority of individual states to enforce local gambling laws against them.

According to the regulator, derivatives markets need consistent rules across the United States rather than different operating requirements in each state. However, several states have challenged this interpretation in court, with multiple federal appellate courts supporting state-level restrictions.

The senators highlighted court orders affecting prediction market operations in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as restrictions involving two California tribal communities. These rulings have required platforms to stop offering certain contracts and maintain geographic restrictions.

The lawmakers argued that the CFTC should withdraw its directive until the ongoing legal disputes are settled. They also warned that encouraging platforms to operate in restricted jurisdictions could undermine state and tribal authority.

The dispute has expanded beyond those states. Louisiana recently secured a court decision allowing state officials to move forward with restrictions on prediction market contracts. The state's gaming regulator has previously classified certain sports-related and other event contracts as illegal gambling.

A temporary restraining order targeted several companies, including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini and Crypto.com. The CFTC responded by filing its own lawsuit to challenge the state's efforts.

The agency has also taken legal action against Arkansas, bringing the number of states it has sued to around a dozen. Arkansas had previously filed its own case against Kalshi on Nov. 4, accusing the company of operating an illegal gambling business.

The regulatory dispute is developing as the CFTC faces changes in its leadership. Selig is currently the agency's only commissioner, despite the commission being designed to have five members.

The White House has nominated two additional candidates to fill vacant positions: Nathan Anonick, a Republican Senate Agriculture Committee staff member, and Matthew Rowland, a former senior adviser to a Democratic commissioner.

The Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC, scheduled a confirmation hearing for both nominees on Tuesday. Democrats are also set to take control of the committee's majority in less than two months, potentially changing the direction of congressional oversight of prediction markets.

With state and federal authorities continuing to challenge each other's jurisdiction, the future of prediction market regulation in the United States remains uncertain. The conflicting court decisions could eventually require a ruling from the U.S. Supreme Court.