CFTC Moves to Dismiss CME Lawsuit Over Crypto Perpetual Futures

The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission is pushing back against a lawsuit from CME Group over the regulator’s handling of cryptocurrency perpetual futures, arguing that the exchange has not shown it suffered any actual harm.

In a filing Wednesday with the US District Court for the District of Columbia, attorneys for CFTC Chair Michael Selig and the agency asked the court to dismiss CME’s case. They also requested an oral hearing to argue their position.

At the heart of the dispute is how the CFTC has classified and approved crypto perpetual futures. CME sued the agency in June after the regulator allowed prediction markets platform Kalshi to offer Bitcoin perpetual futures and issued a no-action position covering similar products offered by Coinbase.

CME argued that the CFTC had overstepped its authority by treating the contracts as swaps rather than futures. The exchange also claimed Selig acted without the full five-member commission, which CME said conflicted with requirements under the Commodity Exchange Act.

The CFTC strongly disagrees.

According to the agency’s latest filing, CME cannot establish a specific financial injury because other CFTC-registered exchanges are also permitted to offer comparable digital-asset futures products. The commission said CME has not claimed that it is legally or practically prevented from listing perpetual futures itself.

The agency went as far as describing the lawsuit as “much ado about nothing,” arguing that the exchange’s complaint is based on a regulatory decision that does not prevent CME from competing in the same market.

The dispute has already produced sharp criticism from both sides. Following CME’s original lawsuit, a CFTC spokesperson accused the exchange of engaging in “lawfare” and dismissed the complaint as frivolous.

CME’s legal challenge comes as perpetual futures become an increasingly important part of the crypto derivatives market. Unlike traditional futures contracts, perpetuals generally do not have fixed expiration dates, allowing traders to maintain positions indefinitely as long as margin requirements are met.

For the CFTC, the case could also have broader implications for how crypto derivatives are treated under US commodities law. CME is effectively challenging the regulatory framework being applied to a growing class of digital-asset products.

Selig and the CFTC are now asking the court to hear their arguments for dismissal. As of Thursday, however, no hearing had been placed on the court’s public docket.

The court’s decision could determine whether CME’s challenge moves forward and potentially provide further clarity on the regulator’s authority over crypto perpetual futures.